Expelling the myth of “Zen Buddhism influence among the warrior class of Japan”
Responding to:
Let’s Stop the sad times from returning to Japan!
Gomendesai wrote:
I beg to disagree. Hara-kiri was a tradition among the bravest of all soldiers earth has ever seen. The ideal of self-immolation – death before dishonor – come from the Zen Buddhist influence among the warrior class of Japan. It had high ideals of honor until death, frugality, loyalty, etc etc….. these are what some of the WWII soldiers had followed. They were the modern warriors of Japan with an older set of ideals/values/beliefs.
By cutting of his head he was giving him the honor he deserved as a defeated enemy. There was no more barbarism in that than killing your enemy with a “shotgun to the face”.
What about the Atomic bombings? They were war-crimes against all of humanity…. We cannot forget that.
My reply:
First let me clarify this point: Yasuno Chikao, the executioner in the above photograph, committed a cold-blooded murder when he beheaded the Australian soldier.
Human life is sacred, regardless of how “Zen Buddhism” may or may not have influenced “the warrior class of Japan.”
The “high ideals of honor until death, frugality, loyalty…” mean nothing if they didn’t follow “avoidance of war,” first and foremost.
What is so honorable about raping and killing other human beings, torching their homes, and then, when you can no longer fight, committing suicide, leaving your mother, wife, daughter, sister… at the mercy of your enemy to rape and murder… your home and possessions torched and ransacked…
You call this brand of ultra cowardice bravery? Honor? Ideals? Values? Beliefs? Superiority of “modern warriors of Japan with an older set of ideals” over all others? Zen Buddhism?
What about the fate of your family, your wife and children, after you go to battle, lose the war and commit seppuku? Don’t they have a right? Don’t they matter? Of course NOT! Zen Buddhism is a men’s thing; women and children have no place in it—they don’t have a soul!
The words cowardly, bad, ugly, selfish, among many other adjectives, come to mind when you speak about the “Zen Buddhist influence.”
Do you speak for the “slave-class,” which is imbued with these phony ideals and falsities, or the “master-class,” trying to “protect” your kind by keeping these predatory, antisocial “codes of conduct” alive?
Suicide is cowardly. “Hara-kiri” or “seppuku” is a “slave-class” tradition, designed to protect the master class. How else would you prevent “samurai” from refusing to fight each other, or stop them from changing masters?
“Hara-kiri” served the master class even in wartime Okinawa—committing suicide wasn’t an option. Not only soldiers, but ordinary people were ordered to kill themselves, when the Imperial Army felt they may give away sensitive information to the “enemy.” You may recall that 171 people on Zamami Island and 329 people on Tokashiki Island committed suicide towards the end of World War II. The grenades were supplied by the army. See below for reference links
- http://japanifik.wordpress.com/2008/03/29/japanese-army-deeply-involved/
- http://japanifik.wordpress.com/2008/03/30/jumping-in-junity/
- http://japanifik.wordpress.com/2008/03/02/a-word-for-ryukyuans/
You also said: “What about the Atomic bombings? They were war-crimes against all of humanity…. We cannot forget that.”
The atomic bombing, regardless of any excuses offered by the apologists after the war, were “crimes against all of humanity.”
However, I detect a note of inconsistency in your comment. You cannot sincerely condemn “the Atomic bombings” as “crimes against all of humanity,” without equally condemning “war,” “Hara-kiri,” “seppuku,” the “master-slave,” class distinction … and “Zen Buddhism,” if in fact the latter influenced everything else. See also:
- http://japanifik.wordpress.com/2008/11/07/apa-goblin-japans-asdf-and-the-crazy-general/
- http://japanifik.wordpress.com/2008/11/02/tamogamis-history-lies/